San Francisco Leaders OK
Plastic Grocery Bag Ban

LISA LEFF / AP / Washington Post 27mar2007

 

Mindfully.org note
This is only a partial victory for San Francisco. The public must be forced to use only reusable bags. Single-use bags are not acceptable considering how many get used once and thrown away. And biodegradable plastic is itself an oxymoron because it breaks down only far enough to be out of sight while the toxic parts of it remain almost indefinitely.

The statement by the NRDC  representative, Craig Noble, shows a lack of understanding.

Plastic bags, whether regular or "biodegradable" are just one more false choice that allows people to remain ignorant about single-use bags.

Mindfully.org endorses a ban on all plastic bags with a stiff fee on paper bags.

More on Plastic | Other Bans

City leaders approved a ban on plastic grocery bags after weeks of lobbying on both sides from environmentalists and a supermarket trade group. If Mayor Gavin Newsom signs the ban as expected, San Francisco would be the first U.S. city to adopt such a rule.

The law, passed by a 10-1 vote, requires large markets and drug stores to give customers only a choice among bags made of paper that can be recycled, plastic that breaks down easily enough to be made into compost, or reusable cloth.

San Francisco supervisors and supporters said that by banning the petroleum-based sacks, blamed for littering streets and choking marine life, the measure would go a long way toward helping the city earn its green stripes.

"Hopefully, other cities and states will follow suit," said Supervisor Ross Mirkarimi, who crafted the ban after trying to get a 15-cent per bag tax passed in 2005.

The 50 grocery stores that would be most affected by the law argued that the ban was not reasonable because plastic bags made of corn byproducts are a relatively new, expensive and untested product. Some said they might offer only paper bags at checkout.

"I think what grocers will do now that this has passed is, they will review all their options and decide what they think works best for them economically," said David Heylen, a spokesman for the California Grocers Association.

Newsom supported the measure. The switch is scheduled to take effect in six months for grocery stores and in one year for pharmacies.

Craig Noble, a spokesman for the Natural Resources Defense Council [NRDC], said it would be disappointing if grocers rejected the biodegradable plastic bag option, since more trees would have to be cut down if paper bag use increases.

The new breed of bags "offers consumers a way out of a false choice, a way out of the paper or plastic dilemma," Noble said.

source: 27mar2007

To send Mindfully.org your comments, questions, and suggestions click here
The home page of this website is www.mindfully.org
Please see our Fair Use Notice