Full Speed Ahead
JAMES di PROPERZIO / University of Chicago Magazine 1feb04
Unconventional and undeterred, biologist Lynn Margulis, AB’57, has seen some of her once-revolutionary ideas on evolution win mainstream acceptance. As for the rest, she’s still pressing on.
On a cold November morning in Amherst, Massachusetts, Lynn Margulis, 65 years old and without a helmet, is riding her secondhand Miyata 10-speed—its two side baskets full of books, mail, and lunch—down the sidewalk to her laboratory at the University of Massachusetts, where she holds the title Distinguished University Professor in the Department of Geosciences. At 6 a.m. it is barely light, shops are closed, and the town is quiet. But Margulis, a short, graying dynamo, confides, “I do my best work when no one is around.”
Her best work isn’t bad: elected to the National Academy of Sciences in 1983 and awarded the National Medal of Science in 1999, Margulis has her ninth book behind her (the paperback edition of Acquiring Genomes: A Theory of the Origins of Species was published in July 2003), more than 200 scientific articles, and dozens of popular essays to her name. This week Margulis, AB’57, also has a to-do list that includes carrying out lab work with termite protists; publishing research on symbiotic bacteria; shopping for an American publisher for her novel about love and scientists, Luminous Fish; finishing a book on pioneering landscape architect and ecologist Ian L. McHarg; and creating lecture videos.
On today’s agenda at the Morrill Science Center is the premiere of her new teaching video, Green Animals. After Margulis cues up the tape and fields questions from the 30-some advanced undergraduates, graduate students, and professors, Green Animals begins its up-close and technical footage of sea slugs (naked-eye views of whole slugs give way to highly-magnified microscopic frames). These are no ordinary images and no ordinary slugs—they are living proof of her most famous theory.
I grew up on the South Side of Chicago,” Margulis says of braving the morning’s bitter chill on her bicycle. “I’m not afraid of anything.” Indeed, Margulis boldly makes claims that fly in the face of accepted scientific thought. As the self-appointed spokesperson for the 250,000 extant species of microorganisms, she has made foundational contributions to modern biology. Once thought outrageously heterodox, her theory of symbiosis as an evolutionary mechanism—the “endosymbiotic hypothesis,” which posits that the ancestors of mitochondria in animal cells and the plastids in algae and plants were once free-living organisms—is now considered fundamental to understanding evolution.
Margulis also made an important contribution to taxonomy with the 1982 publication of Five Kingdoms. With coauthor Karlene V. Schwartz, then a UMass–Boston biology instructor, she literally rewrote the book on classification, discarding the old plant/animal system that tried to cram hundreds of millions of microscopic beings into the two kingdoms of organisms visible to the naked eye. Through her work on microbes’ interactions with sedimentary rocks and atmospheric chemistry—and vice versa—she has provided support for James Lovelock’s Gaia hypothesis, the theory that Earth’s biota, working in concert with its environment, acts as a single, self-regulating living system maintaining conditions that are suitable for life. Her latest research, presented in Acquiring Genomes (Basic Books, 2002), cowritten with son Dorion Sagan, concerns what she calls symbiogenesis—a kind of horizontal evolution in which new species occur through symbiosis, as temporary partnerships between organisms grow into more permanent relationships.
“Scientists are mostly instrumentalists, but she’s an innovator—often ahead, not always right, but right enough of the time,” says Peter H. Raven, director of the Missouri Botanical Gardens and author of a number of standard biology texts. Margulis’s championing of the symbiotic theory of cell evolution, Raven says, “marks her as someone who has made an extraordinary contribution, a revolution in thinking about the cell—and it is nothing less than a revolution.”
Like her science, Margulis’s personal life is anything but conventional. The mother of four and the grandmother of seven mountain climbs, in-line roller-skates, cross-country skis, and bicycles regularly. In the summer she skinny-dips in a secluded pond on the outskirts of town every evening after work, marveling at the dam-building beavers that share the water with her. Married and divorced twice, she has had a personal and research partnership with her “compañero,” University of Barcelona microbiologist Ricardo Guerrero, for more than 20 years.
Born in Chicago in 1938, Lynn Alexander, along with her three siblings, attended the University’s Laboratory Schools; she applied to the College at age 14. Self-described as bossy, rude, hyperactive, and self-centered, she was eager to get away from home, where her parents, an attorney and a housewife, were socialites and drinkers. “They did everything I can’t stand,” Margulis exclaims.
She enrolled in the College at 16 and that same year, while heading up the Eckhart Hall stairs, she met a 19-year-old physics grad student on his way down. “Everyone knew who he was,” Margulis recalls of Carl Sagan, AB’54, SB’55, SM’56, PhD’60, who would become a professor of astronomy at Cornell University, the host of the TV show Cosmos, and a well-known popularizer of science. Sagan was tall, handsome, and articulate, and it was love in an instant. Three years later, on June 16, 1957, the week after she received her bachelor’s degree, they were married. The couple had two sons—Dorion, a writer, born in 1959, and Jeremy, a music-software developer and composer, born in 1960.
While fascinated by Sagan’s interest in astronomy, it was not his influence that started her on a science career. She had come to the University hoping to be a writer. As she details in the autobiographical Symbiotic Planet (Basic Books, 1998), Margulis locates her initial impetus toward science in a single course: Natural Science 2, required as part of the Common Core. Nat. Sci. 2 entailed reading primary sources, and Gregor Mendel’s classic experiments on breeding garden peas drove Margulis to learn as much as she could about heredity and genetics.
It wasn’t until she was 19 and in graduate school, studying genetics at the University of Wisconsin–Madison under Walter Plaut, that Margulis first saw amoebae—through the phase-contrast microscopes in Plaut’s laboratory. “I really liked amoebae,” she laughs. “I still do.” She got to see them at close range, siphoning out dead ones with the dirty water, then adding salt solution and food. Margulis recalls this task fondly: “I owe my passion for working on Saturday nights to the utter necessity of amoebae feeding and bowl cleaning every day.”
While working in Plaut’s lab and earning a master’s degree in zoology-genetics, she was intrigued by the curiously independent nature of mitochondria and became a proponent of endosymbiosis—a theory first introduced in the 1920s—that would come to have a profound influence on all of her later research. Endosymbiosis occurs when one organism takes up permanent residence in another, creating a single functional organism.
An example of endosymbiosis can be seen in Margulis’s Green Animals video as the sea slugs pierce algae and keep the algae’s chloroplast, or energy-making cells, alive in their translucent gut. There the plastids photosynthesize and supply the slugs’ nutriment, while the slugs in turn provide an ideal environment for the plastids. Examining the slug’s genome reveals a gene for a protein useless to animals. Somehow the gene, otherwise found only in algae, has been passed from the algal to the slug’s cells.
On a larger scale, endosymbiosis suggests that both the mitochondria of animal cells and the chloroplasts of plant cells, both of which have independent genomes totally unlike the genomes of their host cells, were originally free-living bacteria engulfed by other cells but not digested. The bacteria stayed on, giving their hosts the chemical energy they needed to be healthier and more vigorous, and in turn received what they required from the host (and, in the case of chloroplasts, the sun).
Margulis’s major theoretical and interpretive work since then has radiated from the concept of integral symbiosis: a reunderstanding of the kingdoms of life and their relationships. Symbiosis is not limited to the level of chloroplasts and sea slugs: the entire ecosystem of the planet in physical contact with the air is one great symbiosis as seen from space. As life produces oxygen and other reactive gases, it fosters its own environment. For Margulis, much of evolution is thus a symbiotic endeavor in which interaction and merger lead to persistence.
Her fascination with symbiosis, however, did not bring her immediate success. Her 1967 paper “Origin of Mitosing Cells” was ignored or rejected by more than 20 publishers—although it later generated 800 reprint requests, won the Boston University faculty publication award, and formed the basis for her first book, Origin of Eukaryotic Cells: Evidence and Research Implications for a Theory of the Origin and Evolution of Microbial, Plant and Animal Cells on the Precambrian Earth (Yale University Press, 1970).
After Sagan was offered a postdoc at the University of California, Berkeley, the family moved to Oakland, and Margulis continued her doctorate. Unable to spend a required semester at a marine laboratory because of the demands of childcare, she ended up focusing on genetics with a zoology thesis director, Max Alfert. Alfert was a formidable mentor: “He graduated almost no one,” Margulis says. When Sagan joined Harvard’s astronomy department in 1963, she left Berkeley with her dissertation almost completed. Difficulties in convening her committee kept her from filing for her degree until 1965, after she had published her thesis, “Unusual Pattern of Thymidine Incorporation in the Cytoplasm of Euglena,” in the Journal of Protozoology.
Margulis lectured and worked in labs at Brandeis University before landing a part-time job in Boston University’s biology department, where she went from adjunct to full professor in ten years. Although she’d agreed to give her marriage a final, three-month try in Boston, she found the needs of two small children and an equally demanding husband overwhelming, and in 1964 she and Sagan divorced. (Although they saw each other infrequently, they remained colleagues and friends until Sagan’s 1996 death.)
In Boston she met her second husband, Thomas N. Margulis, an X-ray crystallographer teaching at Brandeis. Her third son, Zachary, now a lawyer in New York City, was born in 1967, and her daughter, Jennifer, a writer, was born in 1969. But again, marriage proved a struggle. “I quit my job as a wife twice,” she says of her second divorce, which came 13 years after Jennifer’s birth. “It’s not humanly possible to be a good wife, a good mother, and a first-class scientist. No one can do it—something has to go.”
Indeed, ever since Chicago’s fixed curriculum introduced her to biology, she has suffered the tension of balancing science and personal life. Two years ago the Spanish publisher Tusquets brought out her novel exploring this tension, Luminous Fish, a group of stories following the interconnected lives of several scientists across the globe as their dedication to research tears at their love lives and families. The book, translated by Vicente Campos, has sold well, but she is still seeking a publisher for the English original.
As she continued her research at Boston University Margulis realized that life’s most important division was not plants versus animals. Instead, the great divide came between bacteria and all other organisms—protoctists, fungi, plants, and animals. Members of the last four groups, whether microscopic or enormous, are composed of cells with nuclei. For her, the implication was clear: bacterial cells (without nuclei) are the basic units of life, and all other organisms (with nuclei) are composite multiples. Once she came to this conclusion, traditional science seemed outdated. “Having to teach stuff that was half-true or untrue, based on a false dichotomy between animals and plants,” she says, “led me to want to document the problem.”
So with Karlene Schwartz (now a Boston University biology professor), she collected information from myriad colleagues to write Five Kingdoms. In the book—named by American Scientist magazine in 1999 as “One of the 100 (Or So) Books that Shaped a Century of Science”—they show that five categories of organisms are relevant as rational kingdom divisions: plants, animals, bacteria, protoctists (single-celled organisms with nuclei, such as amoebae, protozoa, and slime molds, and their multicellular descendants), and fungi. This system also provided an evolutionary perspective on the taxonomic groups, needed since Lamarck originated the theory of evolution.
Quick to place her work on a continuum, Margulis points out that Five Kingdoms had two notable predecessors: Robert H. Whittaker, a Cornell University ecologist who, she says, “removed all fungi from the plant kingdom,” and H. F. Copeland, a botanist at Sacramento State College, on whom Whittaker’s own work was based. Copeland had previously divided life into four kingdoms, placing all fungi in the protoctists. “I sent [Copeland] some of my work and he wrote back to me from the hospital after suffering a heart attack,” Margulis recalls. He praised her work but warned that “none of it would ever be accepted in professional biological journals.”
While Margulis and Schwartz were writing Five Kingdoms, an atmospheric chemist named James Lovelock contacted Margulis, whom he’d met through Sagan, with a question: was it possible that atmospheric methane comes from any life process? Lovelock was puzzled by the fact that methane gas is dramatically more abundant in Earth’s atmosphere—30 orders of magnitude higher—than predicted by physical and chemical forces alone. Speculating that methane and many other atmospheric gases could not have reached their current abundance in an oxygen-rich world, Lovelock theorized that such levels could not be maintained without the enormous influence of biology.
Margulis believed that an important source of methane, one of the greenhouse gases that raises the planet’s atmospheric temperature, is bacteria—found, for example, in cow rumen. When bacteria break down grass during the cow’s digestive process, the methane produced as ruminant burps joins the methane from other bacterial sources (swamps, sewage sludge, animal intestines) to influence atmospheric temperature and gas.
Together Lovelock and Margulis wrote an essay, “The Atmosphere as Circulatory System of the Biosphere—The Gaia Hypothesis,” which appeared in the Summer 1975 CoEvolution Quarterly. In Greek mythology Gaia was the Earth goddess, and in the Gaia hypothesis, Lovelock and Margulis argue, certain aspects of the atmosphere (temperature, composition of gases, oxidation-reduction state, and acidity) form a homeostatic system, and these properties are products of evolution. The atmosphere is a nonliving, actively regulated part of the biosphere, the total system of atmosphere, water, geology, and life on Earth.
“Homo sapiens sapiens are filled with arrogance—we think we are at the center of the universe and the center of life on Earth,” Margulis grumbles. “But Gaia teaches us that humans are not at the center—in fact, they aren’t even central to life on Earth. Bacteria have survived devastating impacts. Bacteria thrive on what we see as pollution, they will survive a nuclear winter. We think we have the power to wipe out life, but we only have the power to wipe out ourselves, our pets, our corn, and other visible totems of our lifestyle. All the life you see with the naked eye is just the tip of the iceberg.”
After 22 years at BU, in 1989 Margulis joined the biology department at UMass Amherst. She now lives next door to the 19th-century home of Amherst’s famous belle, the poet Emily Dickinson, and was inspired to name her 1997 book of essays Slanted Truths, which she and cowriter Dorion Sagan dedicated to Carl Sagan, after a Dickinson poem:
Tell all the Truth, but tell it slant—
Success in Circuit lies
Too bright for our infirm Delight
The Truth’s superb surprise
As Lightning to the Children eased
With explanation kind
The Truth must dazzle gradually
Or every man be blind—
The dazzling truth that Margulis presents in Acquiring Genomes, as in her teaching video Green Animals, explains how symbiogenesis acts as a major mechanism of evolution. Subtitled “A Theory of the Origins of Species,” the book is in part a dialogue with Lamarck—who proposed that new characteristics might arise during an organism’s lifetime in response to a challenge and that, if successful, they would be passed on to offspring—and Darwin—who refined Lamarck’s theory by adding natural selection. Darwin, although doubting that any characteristics arising during a single lifetime could be passed on, was nonetheless at a loss to explain the source of innovation, the new characteristics by which emergent species vary from related species.
Margulis’s theoretical work, meanwhile, argues that most life evolves by trading whole genomes, as happens routinely in the microbial world; and the mergers of whole bacteria into other cells, forming a thriving symbiosis, is the source of all larger life. Her latest paper describes a species of protoctist, Staurojoenina assimilis, with striations across its surfaces. Those distinguishing tiny zebra stripes, Margulis and her colleagues have discovered, although always found on the protist, were not originally part of its body. Rather they are rod-shaped bacteria attached to the surface in “obligate” symbiosis: you don’t find one without the other.
For Margulis such careful examination of a tiny organism recalls her days of washing amoebae—and continues to give her food for thought. “I care about the science—I always go back to the science,” she says. “I try to reconstruct the history of the cell from modern clues including the fossil record—that is the central idea.”
She takes pride in the fact that her ideas are now becoming a part of the larger body of scientific thought. “Two of my four original postulates are now accepted as correct by all knowledgeable scientists,” she says, lapsing into science-speak, “that mitochondria come from oxygen-respiring alpha proteobacteria—we even know the details—and that plastids evolved from cyanobacteria.
“The third part of the idea,” she continues, “is that the basic cytoplasm that did the trapping evolved from acid- and heat-resistant archaebacteria, like Thermoplasma acidophilum. This is now supported by lots of evidence, mainly put together by my UMass colleagues, Dennis Searcy and Michael Dolan.”
Her fourth postulate from graduate-school days is the idea that cilia and sperm tails have spirochete ancestors—corkscrew-shaped, wriggly bacteria that attached to other organisms and developed a symbiosis that functions in movement and sensation. According to this argument, the rods and cones of our eyes are descendants of light-sensitive swimming bacteria, which once had the structure of independent cells and their own complement of DNA. Once again, most scientists think that she has gone too far, and peer reviewers have refused to approve her federal research grants, cut to zero over the last two years.
But Margulis, characteristically shrugging off the criticism, remains optimistic. “I think we are finally in a position to prove” the spirochete postulate. “I do think we can now, with the use of the new molecular-biology techniques, show the bacterial origins of the cilia, sperm tails, and other motile and sensory microtubular structures of cells. In fact,” she adds with the relentless drive that propels her early-morning bike rides, “we have big plans for next year.”
James di Properzio, a graduate of St
John’s College, is a freelance writer and editor of scientific and literary
texts. He lives in Greenfield, Massachusetts.
Graphic above by göttlich from photo at http://chronicle.uchicago.edu/000203/margulis.jpg 4mar04
Lynn Margulis Distinguished University Professor Member, National Academy of Science
A.B., University of Chicago, 1957 M.S., University of Wisconsin, 1960 Ph.D., U. California, Berkeley, 1963
Postdoctoral: '77 Sherman Fairchild Fellow, California Institute of Technology '79 Guggenheim Fellow '83 Año sabãtico en España
Microbial Symbionts and Organelle Heredity Work continues on the serial endosymbiotic theory, which posits the origin of cell organelles by hereditary symbiosis. Although it seems clear that plastids and mitochondria began as cyanobacteria and respiring bacteria respectively, the question remains of whether undulipodia (cilia and eukaryotic "flagella") originated from associations of spirochetes with Thermoplasma-like archaebacteria. We are investigating the possibility that axonemal proteins like tektins or tubulin are present in spirochetes and continue to work on our recent discoveries of the complex life history in a large composite spirochete, Spirosymplokus deltaeiberi. John Ashen (M.S., 1992) found Diplocalyx, a symbiont of Cryptotermes cavifrons to contain structures resembling microtubule organizing centers. Field and laboratory studies of live microbial mats which resemble prePhanerozoic stromatolitic cherts, in which the earliest fossils have been found, are also under way. Several microbes from the extant mats and their potential for preservation are under study, i.e. the ciliate Pseudo-cohnilembus. Procedures used include standard cytological, microbiological and isotope techniques, fluorescence and video microscopy, immunocytochemistry and gel electrophoresis.
- Margulis L, JO Corlis, M Melkonian and DJ Chapman, editors. 1990. Handbook of Protoctista: The structure, cultivation, habitats and life histories of eukaryotic microorganisms and descendants exclusive of animals, plant and fungi. Jones & Bartlett, Boston, 914pp.
- Margulis L, L Olendzenski and BF Afzelius. 1990. Endospore-forming filamentous bacteria symbiotic in termites: ultrastructure and growth and growth in culture of Arthromitus. Symbiosis 8:95-116.
- Margulis L and G Hinkle. 1992. Large symbiotic spirochetes: Clevelandina, Cristispira, Diplocalyx, Hollandina, and Pillotina. In The Prokaryotes, Handbook of the Biology of Bacteria, V.4 2nd ed. HG Barlows, MG Truper, M Dworkin, W Harder and KH Scheifer, eds. Springer Verlag, NY, pp3965-3978.
- Margulis L. 1992. Biodiversity: Molecular biological domains, symbiosis and kingdom origins. Biosystems 27:39-51
- Margulis L, L Olendzenski and HI McKhann. 1993. Illustrated Glossary of the Protoctista. Jones & Bartlett, Boston, (in press)
- Margulis L, R Guerrero, JB Ashen and M Solé. Largest free-living spirochete found in microbial mats. Proc. Nat'l. Acad. Sci. USA (in press)
(Last revised August 1993)
source: http://www.bio.umass.edu/faculty/biog/margulis.html 4mar04
Acquiring Genomes: A Theory of the Origins of Species
By Lynn Margulis, Dorion Sagan, Ernst Mayr
Paperback / May 2003 / 0465043925
Acquiring Genomes: A Theory of the Origins of Species
By Lynn Margulis, Dorion Sagan
Hardcover / July 2002 / 0465043917
Symbiotic Planet: A New Look at Evolution
By Lynn Margulis
Paperback / September 1999 / 0465072720
Microcosmos; Four Billion Years of Evolution from Our Microbial Ancestors: Four Billion Years of Evolution from Our Microbial Ancestors
By Lynn Margulis, Dorion Sagan
Paperback / May 1997 / 0520210646
Early Life: Evolution on the Precambrian Earth
By Lynn Margulis, Michael F. Dolan
Paperback / April 2002 / 0763714631
By Lynn Margulis
Paperback / December 1998 / 0805072527
The Biosphere: Complete Annotated Edition
By Vladimir Vernadsky, V. I. Vernadskii, Lynn Margulis
Hardcover / August 1997 / 038798268X
Cloning the Buddha: The Moral Impact of Biotechnology
By Richard Heinberg, Lynn Margulis, Dorion Sagan
Hardcover / August 1999 / 0835607720
Diversity of Life: The Illustrated Guide to Five Kingdoms
By Lynn Margulis, Karlene V. Schwartz, Michael Dolan
Other Format / May 1999 / 0763708623
Environmental Evolution: Effects of the Origin & Evolution of Life on Planet Earth
By Lynn Margulis
Hardcover / May 2000 / 0262133660