US Government's Lack of Safety Standards for GM Crops Revealed 

Press Release / Consumers International 10jan03

Brussels - Documentation showing that the US government allows the biotechnology industry to police itself on safety testing of GM crops will be presented today at a meeting hosted by the German Marshall Fund in Brussels on GM crops, by Consumers International representative, Dr. Michael Hansen.

Dr. Hansen will provide letters written by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to Monsanto accepting at face value Monsanto's own conclusions regarding the safety of their GM corn variety (see attached media briefing for excerpts of the letters)

Dr. Hansen also states that, contrary to the impression given by US ambassadors in Europe and elsewhere, the US government does not have rigorous standards for safety assessments on GM crops, does not thoroughly review company data, and has never formally approved any of the GM corn varieties grown in the US.

These allegations come at a critical time as the US government is making every effort to persuade both European and African governments that GM crops are thoroughly reviewed and that anyone raising questions about safety is ignorant and acting immorally.

"Consumers worldwide and especially in the US are outraged that the US government is threatening the EU with WTO challenges for refusing to accept GM corn until comprehensive labelling and traceability systems are in place, when they themselves do not formally review and approve the safety of the GM corn varieties grown in the US" said Dr. Hansen.

Dr. Hansen further criticized the FDA for failing to follow through on regulatory improvements proposed in 2001. "Back in 1992, the FDA claimed that GM technology is similar to traditional breeding and would therefore be regulated in the same way (see attached media briefing for excerpts from FDA's policy document). Then, in 2001, the FDA admitted that there is a difference between traditional breeding and GM technology and proposed that there should be mandatory notification of GM food marketing and a mandatory FDA data review. However, they have still not issued any such regulation"

Consumers Union (CU) in the US and Consumers International (CI) worldwide are calling on the US government to stop pressurising the EU and Africa to accept its GM corn and instead get its own house in order by conducting mandatory safety reviews of data provided by the biotechnology industry and prohibiting the marketing of GM crops unless they have been approved by the FDA. CU and CI point out that Africa's food needs could be met with non-GMO foods. They note that 70 % of the corn grown in the US is not genetically modified.

Notes to Editors Michael Hansen, Ph.D. is a Senior Research Associate focusing on biotechnology for the Consumers Policy Institute, a division of Consumers Union, the largest consumer organization in the United States. He represents Consumers International at UN bodies that establish international standards on genetically modified food, including the Codex Committee on Food Labelling and the Codex Ad Hoc Task Force on Foods Derived from Modern Biotechnology. For more information, see www.consumersunion.org

Consumers International is a federation of consumer organisations dedicated to the protection and promotion of consumers' rights worldwide through empowering national consumer groups and campaigning at the international level. It currently represents over 250 organisations in 115 countries. For more information, see: www.consumersinternational.org

Consumers International position on the issue of GM food aid to Africa can be seen in the attached letter to James Morris, Director of the World Food Programme. Click here to see full letter: http://www.consumersinternational.org/documents_asp/ViewADocument.asp?regid=135&ID=503&categoryid=463&langID=1 

For further information on the African consumer movement's position on GM crops, please click here: http://www.consumersinternational.org/News/display.asp?id=175&regionid=135&t ag=X&type=news&langid=1

If you have come to this page from an outside location click here to get back to mindfully.org